Skip navigation.

GARDENING GUIDE PT. 2

PROPAGATING CROPS FROM SEED

The experience of planting a seed and watching it grow into a mature plant is a window into mystery like few others. It never fails to evoke feelings of wonder and awe in those who stop to contemplate it, or who simply let the reality of it sink into their bones. How can so much information be contained in such a tiny package? Of course, this same miracle of life operates all around us, among all creatures which reproduce.

Scientifically, we know that DNA in the nucleus of cells contains the information that determines the characteristics of living organisms as they attempt to ensure that their genes survive beyond their individual deaths. We can read about this phenomenon, and even be amazed by it intellectually. The term “seed” is tossed around freely in our language as a metaphor. Whether sprinkled on a hamburger bun or as the basis of whole-grain meals, edible seeds are part of most of our daily lives. And yet, for a deep “grokking” of what a seed is, few experiences can match that of actually taking a seed in one’s hand, planting it, and watching what happens. Many spiritual traditions and rituals (particularly those of indigenous agriculturalists) have arisen from the miracle of the seed, which continues to inspire mystical revelations even among those who did not grow up in religious traditions explicitly grounded in the earth and its cycles. It takes only a little planting experience to understand the appeal of the Beetless’ anthem, ALL YOUR SEEDS ARE LOVE.

Many gardeners buy vegetable starts to transplant into their gardens, but those who do so miss out on a crucial first step. Starting crops from seed can involve some additional work and require extra attention, but it can save significant amounts of money, and, more importantly, exposes gardeners directly to the miracle that ultimately underlies our food-growing activities. At Lost Valley, we raise all of the crops we can from seeds that we sow ourselves, although we sometimes plant transplants as well (usually excess transplants donated to us).

When possible, we save our own seeds and start our crops from those. (See the Seed Saving section.) We also plant many donated seeds and seeds acquired at seed swaps. Whenever possible, we use organically grown, open-pollinated seeds. Specific information on seed viability is often listed on seed packets, and is also available in seed catalogs and books such as Suzanne Ashworth’s Seed to Seed. Some types of seed are relatively long-lived (many brassicas last five years or more), while others are notoriously short-lived (leeks and onions may not last more than one year). Storage conditions greatly influence seed life and vigor. In general, keeping seeds dry, cold, and dark, while still able to “breathe,” ensures the longest viability. This combination of conditions can be challenging to achieve in our Pacific Northwest climate: dryness and cool do not normally coexist here. During the colder parts of the year, the air is typically quite moist, while low humidity coincides with the relatively warmer temperatures of our dry summers. Ideal storage conditions would involve storage in a freezer of seeds that have been adequately dried. We have usually made do with storage in large mouse-proof but somewhat breathable plastic bins that we try not to let get too hot or too moist.

When sowing in flats (where most of our seed-starting is done—see the Transplanting and Direct Seeding section), we have used either pre-mixed organic soil medium or a mixture we prepare ourselves. We have typically sown seeds in lines in several-inch-high square or rectangular wooden or plastic boxes, with drainage holes or slats on the bottom, and a layer or two of newspaper to keep the soil mixture from falling through the openings. In LOOSELY FIRM THE EDGES OF SEEDFLATS, the Beetless describe one method of seed sowing: sifting compost, adding amendments, filling seedflats with the resulting mixture, tamping the edges, then sowing seeds in furrows and covering them.

Sowing seeds in rows in flats, for later pricking out into larger containers, has several advantages: it conserves space in the greenhouse, allows the extra attention (including watering and protection from birds) needed for sprouting seeds to be concentrated in a small area, and allows selection of the healthiest individuals when pricking out (while not wasting space in six-packs or plug trays on nonviable seed). It also gives the seedlings, once planted in the larger containers, a head start on any weeds, and minimizes the amount of bare soil exposed at any one time (bare soil needs more frequent watering, and, without the close proximity of neighbors, individual plants in larger containers are more likely to be stressed by heat, cold, etc. when they are small). It also eliminates the need for thinning six-packs or plug trays in which more than one seed has sprouted per cell. For the reasons listed above, John Jeavons’ How to Grow More Vegetables advocates the traditional biointensive step-by-step approach, giving plants progressively more room through several stages as they grow—but other approaches are certainly possible. Many commercial operations which have no shortage of space or of larger planting containers and no problem with bird predation, and which have watering systems which can easily keep many sprouting six-packs or plug trays moist, choose to eliminate the extra labor step of pricking out. Smaller-scale gardeners, too, may choose this option. (For further discussion of pricking out and transplanting, see the Transplanting and Direct Seeding section.)

For each crop, seed catalogs and packets typically recommend how many seeds to sow per inch when planting in rows or broadcasting—usually denser than the final spacing (plants will be pricked out or thinned later). If you’re using older seed, which may have a lower germination rate, it’s wise to sow even more thickly than recommended for new seed. Larger seeds are easily individually placed by hand in furrows or pots. With smaller seeds, a “sprinkling method” can be effective: seeds can be held between thumb and forefinger and released by gentle rubbing, or can be gently sprinkled from a palm, packet, or other container. Special seeding boards (with holes punched at appropriate intervals) are sometimes used with plug trays, and mechanical seeders can be used for longer rows in garden beds. Cover crop seeds are usually broadcast by hand, and mechanical seeders are available for this operation as well.

How deep should seeds be planted? This depends on the individual seed, as well as several other factors. Seed packets and catalogs usually recommend certain planting depths for specific crops, but a good general guideline is to cover the seed with about two to three times its diameter in soil. Of course, this will vary. Some seeds, like lettuce, need to be quite shallow in order to germinate—they need some exposure to light, so should be covered with the thinnest layer of soil that will allow light to penetrate while not allowing the seed to dry out (or be plucked away by a bird) on the surface. Shallow planting is also recommended in heavy clay soils, and at times of year when the soil is apt to become waterlogged and/or cold. On the other hand, deep planting can ensure better survival in well-drained soils and in dry and/or overly hot conditions. Here in the Pacific Northwest, especially when the soil is wet and somewhat cool, we will get better results if we plant large seeds like beans and corn relatively shallowly. In the arid Southwest, however, the Hopi traditionally plant their nonirrigated beans and corn quite deep, where they can benefit from the small amounts of moisture that their “planting hole” method helps collect, and be protected from the drying effects of the hot desert sun.

Other factors influencing planting depth can include expected weather conditions during the period of sprouting, whether the seed has been presoaked and presprouted, whether birds, slugs, gophers, or other potential visitors have been or may be expected to be active (see HERE COME THE SLUGS, GOPHER BITES, and ACROSS THE SEED BEDS FIRST), and what medium is being used to cover the seeds, any of which could dictate shallower or deeper planting. Seeds on or near the surface of outside beds may be washed away in a downpour, or may dry out in a drought. Birds feast from above, gophers from below, and slugs from both above and below. A light planting mix can be sprinkled a bit more heavily over seeds than can regular heavy clay garden soil, and still not impede plant growth.

In general, seed flats should end up with an even surface, without mounds, ridges, or furrows, because watering will tend to wash soil from high points to low points. Seeds planted at the bottom of a furrow that is too deep will tend to get covered with more soil, if, when they are initially covered with the correct amount, the soil doesn’t reach the top of the furrow. Seeds planted too shallowly, with extra soil piled on top of them, will tend to be exposed as water begins to level the soil surface. The same principles apply to outside beds, although a mound method has been used in certain conditions for some heat-loving large-seeded crops like beans, corn, squash, cucumbers, and melons (in areas where soils may be too cool and soggy to allow optimal germination), and a sunken method (like that used by the Hopis or by the Zunis in their “waffle gardens”) has been used for some of those same crops where lack of moisture is an issue.

Many of these factors are discussed in the Beetless’ DO YOU WANT TO KNOW THE SEED DEPTH? Other Beetless’ lyrics which refer to seed-sowing include YOU WON'T SEED ME (which advocates collecting and sowing seeds even of those plants that seem to come up well on their own in the garden) and, from the “Beetless Bootleg” APPENDIX, I SHOULD HAVE SOWN BETTER (“a belabored, self-castigating number about why seeds might not have sprouted as desired: planted too deep, too shallow, too thick, too thin, or from stock that had never matured, was poorly stored, was too old, was genetically inferior, of the wrong variety, of the wrong species, or a bad choice to begin with…[d]owner lyrics we don't miss”) and I'M SOW-TIRED (about what happens when one overdoes a good thing).

John Jeavons’ How to Grow More Vegetables lists temperature ranges and optimal soil temperatures for vegetable seed germination, and many sources list typical number of days until seed emergence (which can be affected by soil temperature). Seeds need favorable conditions to germinate, including adequate light, air, and water. Seed flats and seed beds need to be kept moist, especially during that critical period when the seed’s radical (incipient root) is emerging and establishing itself. In some cases, however, too much water can be as bad as not enough: those same large seeds that are especially prone to perish in waterlogged soils or in soils cooled excessively by watering (like beans, corn, and squash) are watered infrequently until emergence. For more details, see the Irrigation section.

 
(forward to Pt. 3) (back to Gardening Guide index)